It's the first question almost every business owner asks me, and it's the hardest one to answer in a single number: "What does a website cost?" The honest answer is that it depends entirely on what you're actually trying to do. A one-page site for a brand-new contractor and a ten-page site with online booking and a payment flow are both "websites," and they're priced nothing alike.
So instead of a fake number, here's how website pricing actually works in Indianapolis in 2026 — the real ranges, what moves the price up or down, and how to figure out which level your business needs.
The three ways to get a website built
1. DIY builders (Wix, Squarespace, GoDaddy)
Roughly $15–$50/month, plus your own time. These are real tools and they work fine for a simple presence. The catch is the part nobody quotes you: the hours. You're the designer, the copywriter, the SEO person, and the support desk. For a lot of owners that "free" build quietly costs two or three weekends and still looks like a template — because it is one.
DIY is the right call when you genuinely just need a placeholder, you have time and patience, and the site isn't a meaningful source of customers yet.
2. A freelancer
Typically $1,000–$4,000 for a small-business site. A good freelancer gets you a real custom design and a human to talk to. The risk is consistency: freelancers get busy, take full-time jobs, or move on, and "who maintains this next year?" becomes your problem. Quality also swings wildly — vet the portfolio and ask who hosts and updates the site after launch.
3. A studio (like No404)
Generally $2,500–$8,000+ for a small-to-mid business site, usually with an ongoing care plan. You're paying for a designed, hand-built site plus someone who's still there in a year when you need a page changed or something breaks. At No404, website packages start at $2,500 for a Starter site and run to $6,000+ for sites with e-commerce and custom integrations — with managed hosting and support included rather than billed as a surprise.
What actually drives the price
Two sites can both cost "a website," and the gap between them is almost always one of these five things:
- Number of pages. A 3-page site is a different amount of work than a 12-page site with service pages, location pages, and an about section. More pages means more design, more copy, more testing.
- Custom design vs. template. Starting from a template is cheap and fast and looks like everyone else. A custom design built around your brand and your sales process takes more hours — and it's usually where the real value is.
- Booking and e-commerce. The moment a site needs to take an appointment or a payment, you've added real functionality: scheduling logic, a cart, checkout, confirmations. That's a step up in scope.
- Integrations. Connecting the site to your CRM, calendar, email marketing, or invoicing tool is what makes it actually useful day to day — and each connection is real work.
- Copywriting and SEO. "Just put my info on it" and "write pages that rank in Indianapolis and convert visitors into calls" are very different jobs.
What you get at each level
Here's a rough map of what each budget buys for a typical Indianapolis small business:
- ~$2,500–$3,500 (Starter): A clean, mobile-friendly custom site of about 5 pages, a contact form, basic SEO, SSL, and managed hosting. Right for newer businesses that need to look professional and get found.
- ~$4,000–$5,500 (Business): Up to ~10 pages, fully custom design, e-commerce or booking readiness, deeper SEO, analytics, and social integration. The sweet spot for established local businesses that get real leads from their site.
- ~$6,000–$8,000+ (Enterprise): Larger sites with a full online store, custom integrations, priority support, and monitoring. For businesses where the website is a core revenue channel.
You can see real and demo examples of each level — a dental practice with online booking, a multi-page law firm site, and a working e-commerce store — on my Work page.
When custom is actually worth it
Not every business needs a custom build, and I'll tell you when you don't. But custom earns its cost when:
- Your website is a real source of leads or sales — not just a digital business card.
- You have a specific sales process the site should follow (the way a fire-protection company or a dental practice books work is not generic).
- You need the site to connect to other tools, take bookings, or take payments.
- You want one person who designs it, builds it, and is still around to support it.
If what you actually need is closer to an internal tool or an application — not a marketing site at all — that's a different conversation, and I wrote a whole guide on telling the difference: Do You Need an App, a Website, or Custom Software?
The bottom line
For most Indianapolis small businesses, a professional, custom-built website lands somewhere in the $3,000–$8,000 range, with a modest monthly care plan to keep it hosted, secure, and updated. Cheaper exists, but you're usually trading away design, support, or both. The right question isn't "what's the cheapest?" — it's "what will this site actually do for my business, and who's standing behind it?"
If you want a straight, no-pitch answer on what your specific project would cost, just email me and tell me what you're trying to do.
Back to Insights